2008 Toyota Prius
We averaged 54.6 mpg during our test of the 2008 Toyota Prius.

Model: 2008 Toyota Prius Base model; 91-horsepower 1.5-liter 4-cylinder and Continuously Variable Transmission (CVT).

Base Price: $22,325

Options: Package Two (antiskid system, rearview camera, AM/FM/CD/MP3 player, digital-media-player connection, keyless access and starting), carpeted floor mats and cargo mat, security system

Price as Tested: $24,718

Total Miles Tested: 707 miles

Fuel Economy: 54.6 mpg

Editors' Comments
Rick Cotta: It's been speculated that Toyota has been far more successful with the Prius than Honda has been with the Civic Hybrid because the Prius has a unique look not shared with a "conventional" car, and thus screams it's eco status at full volume. It has practical advantages as well, including a hatchback body style and a folding rear seatback (which Civic Hybrid forfeits to its battery pack), but it also has more dynamic idiosyncrasies than the Civic that can either be annoying or a friendly reminder that you're getting 45 mpg, depending on your point of view. Honda has apparently gotten the hint, as it's due to release its own dedicated hybrid model (Insight) in the spring of 2009, and it's supposed to cost less than a Prius. So if you can hold out until then, you'll not only have another choice in green transportation, you may also save some money--or at least not have to wait so long in line.
Jennifer Geiger: Prius is an obvious mpg superstar (the 55.4 mpg I averaged during my 532-mile test sounds too good to be true), but you forfeit power and overall usability and comfort. Toyota goes to great lengths to make sure you and everyone else KNOWS you are driving a hybrid. A quirky climate and audio interface system, poor front and rear visibility, and its tendency to frequently and annoyingly beep made this hybrid not especially pleasant during my long trip.
Don Sikora: For the most part, the Toyota Prius is thoroughly unremarkable dynamically, which is probably a true triumph of engineering for a vehicle this specialized. Driven carefully, Prius will squeeze a lot of miles out of a gallon of gas. Over about 175 miles of nearly all non-interstate highway driving I averaged 50.68 mpg. If you value fuel economy, and the obvious visual statement of that value, above all else, for now Prius is in a class by itself.

09.30.2009