2007 Chevrolet Tahoe
2007 Chevrolet Tahoe

 TEST COMPLETE
­Cons­umer Guide is doing something unprecedented for this extended-use evaluation. For half of its yearlong stay, we will run our 2007 Chevrolet Tahoe using E85 ethanol fuel. We'll alternate E85 with conventional gasoline every two months to account for seasonal conditions. Domestic automakers are marketing E85 as a way to promote America's energy independence. Our goal is to determine what effect E85 has on fuel economy and engine performance.


E85 consists of 85 percent ethanol alcohol (refined from corn in the US) and 15 percent gasoline. GM says this alternative fuel is good for the environment because it produces less emissions than regular gasoline without affecting acceleration performance. However, EPA fuel economy estimates are about 25 percent lower with E85 vs. regular gasoline. E85 generally costs less than regular-grade fuel but isn't widely available outside the Midwest.


While our questions about E85 are as yet unanswered, there's little debate about our Tahoe LTZ's appeal. Redesigned for 2007, this large SUV handles well, and the interior ambience is upscale. We dislike its uncomfortable 3rd-row seat and are taken aback by our lavishly equipped tester's $53,455 price.


The 320-hp 5.3-liter V8 engine has fine power, with no noticeable difference in acceleration between using gasoline and E85. Some testers believe acceleration is actually a bit stronger on ethanol. Fuel economy is a different story, as we are averaging 14.1 mpg on gas, but just 11.6 on E85. That's a drop of nearly 20 percent. While it is difficult to quantify the "feel good" factor of using a domestically produced alternative fuel, the economic case for using E85 does not appear to be a strong one.

Editors' Comments

Rick Cotta:
While some might question the merit of such a large, expensive SUV with limited 3rd-row room, Tahoe otherwise acquits itself quite well. Fuel economy on gasoline is no worse than in many smaller V8-powered utes, and the ability to run on E85 may become more valuable in time. Nits include tedious manual adjustment of the automatic climate controls and occasional slow transmission kickdowns, but those are countered by nice-looking interior appointments, a surfeit of room and comfort for four adults, and generally pleasant driving dynamics. Still, unless you want to tow heavy loads--or just surround yourself with lots of metal--any number of smaller, less-expensive SUVs would probably serve just as well.

John Biel:
With $$$$ in options (above and beyond the package necessary to turn an LTZ into an LTZ), this test vehicle's sticker easily clears $50,000. That makes it a pricey proposition to buy and--with low-teens fuel economy--a pricey vehicle to feed. But it is solid, powerful, and comfortable, and an absolute must-see for anyone with legitimate need for the capability this kind of vehicle can provide.

Ed Piotrowski:
The sub 12-mpg performance of this vehicle on E85 makes using ethanol an even more questionable proposition, given that there's no dramatic savings in terms of cost per gallon between the two types of fuel. Still, giving consumers the option to use one fuel or another is never a bad thing.

Tom Appel:
The ideal four-adult long-haul cruiser.

2007 Chevrolet Tahoe
2007 Chevrolet Tahoe
Bodystyle: 4-door wagon
Model: LTZ
Engine: 320-hp 5.3-liter V8
Transmission: 4-speed automatic
Total Miles: 11,353

CG® Observed Fuel Economy (gas): 14.1 mpg
CG® Observed Fuel Economy (E85): 11.6 mpg
Problems During Test: None
Base Price: $37,860
Price as Tested: $53,455
Major Options:

Navigation system, DVD entertainment, sunroof, power running boards, 2nd row bucket seats, rearview camera