Search Consumer Guide Auto and the Web
 

2005-2008 Ford Mustang Road Test
Date Published: 11/23/08
Our road test for this generation Ford Mustang includes a full evaluation from the inside out. We've evaluated every aspect of the Ford Mustang and highlighted the vehicle's performance with pros and cons. Use our comprehensive road test ratings to decide if this generation Ford Mustang is right for you.
2005-2008 Ford Mustang Road Test
Pros Cons
Acceleration Interior materials
Handling/roadholding (GT) Rear-seat room
Automatic-transmission performance (V6)
Rear-seat entry/exit
Consumer Guide® Road-Test Evaluation
The base Mustang's V6 furnishes brisk takeoffs--a test automatic-transmission coupe did 6.9 sec 0-60 mph--but suffers sluggish throttle response that dulls midrange pickup. And Mustang's automatic lacks a manual shift gate. GTs are fast--Ford claimed around 5.2 sec 0-60 with either transmission--but V8 needs at least 3000 rpm for true muscle feel and responds most satisfyingly with manual transmission. Convertibles weigh some 175 lb more than comparable coupes, so are a bit slower. Test automatic-transmission base coupes averaged 19.3-20.4 mpg, a base convertible 19.1 mpg. Test manual-transmission GT coupes averaged 14.6-16.3 mpg, GT convertibles 16.2-17.4 mpg. A test automatic GT coupe averaged 14.9 mpg. With either the V6 or V8, Ford recommends regular-grade fuel. All Mustangs absorb small bumps with little shock, but can transmit sharp pavement breaks. Base models prone to slight float over large moguls. GTs ride a bit firmer than base models. The convertibles' impressively solid structure exhibits little quake or cowl shake. Base Mustangs have good cornering moves, but some testers fault slower steering, more body lean than a sporty car should have. Sure-footed GTs have nicely weighted steering, impressive dry-road grip, and modest lean. All have fine stopping power. Inside, the main gauges are set in tunnellike housings surrounded by shiny trim, making them hard to read by day. Manual shifting can be awkward with the console cupholders in use. Mustang's cabin has eye appeal, but too much hard plastic even for this price level; the console lid and door inserts are among the few padded surfaces. Mustang's switchgear feels cut-rate, and intermittent dashboard squeaks plagued two test coupes. Convertible-top roof latches are balky to operate and require a fair amount of muscle to lock in place. Wind rush is reasonably muffled, even in convertibles, but there's marked coarse-surface tire thrum and fairly loud engines. The V6 growls and booms unpleasantly as revs rise. The V8 has a throaty muscle car tone. There is good head and leg room up front, but the low seats, tall dashtop, and high windowsills create a cozy feel. Driver comfort is enhanced by the standard tilt steering wheel, height-adjustable seat, and nicely contoured backrest. But some testers' knees made unwanted contact with the hard door panel and center console. Shoulder belts don't adjust for height, and run at neck level on some occupants. Overall visibility is good in coupes, but the convertible's top has a wide over-the-shoulder blind spot. The long doors complicate tight-quarters entry/exit. Rear seat space is inhospitable for adults; there's little room, and entry/exit requires back-straining moves. Both Mustang body styles have good trunk space for the class, but not much by absolute standards. Trunklids open wide on nonintruding hinges, but the aperture's size and shape preclude bulky items. An available subwoofer consumes an unacceptable amount of trunk space. Cabin storage is sparse; the door map pockets are almost useless.
Value for the Money
We prefer the GT versions, but any Mustang has all-American bang-for-the-buck appeal. The main letdowns are low-rent cabin appointments and occasional workmanship lapses. V6 versions are close to many sporty imports on price, but not in agility, refinement, or overall quality. GTs deliver usable high performance at relative bargain prices. And no other brand matches Mustang's convertibles for their blend of price, performance, and nominal 4-passenger capacity.
Consumer Guide® Road Test Ratings
Ford Mustang GT Rating
Performance 8
Fuel Economy 4
Ride Quality 4
Steering/Handling/Braking 8
Quietness 4
Controls/Materials 4
Interior Room 6
Room/Comfort (rear) 2
Cargo Capacity 2
Value within Class 8
Total: 50
Each vehicle report contains one rating chart for representative model. Consumer Guide® rates in ten key areas: Performance, Fuel Economy, Ride Comfort, Steering and Handling, Interior Noise, Controls and Materials, Driver Room, Passenger Room, Cargo Capacity, and Insurance Costs. These ratings compare the particular vehicle rated to ALL other vehicles, not a vehicle's standing in a particular class. In the ratings table, "1" is the lowest rating and "10" is the highest rating.
Car Buying Resources

Trade-In Calculator

Research how much your car is truly worth

Trade-In Calculator



Used Cars

Search online classifieds and find a local dealer
Search Local Listings

Vehicle History Report

Get a CARFAX Vehicle History... the first step to protecting yourself from costly hidden problems.



What's Under the Hood?

Learn about how cars work.

Learn things



Insurance

We're dedicated to making insurance easier.

Get Insurance



Sell Your Car

Reach over 8 million buyers
Sell Your Car
    Find a Used Car
Price Range:
to
 Radius:
    Vehicle History Report

FREE CARFAX Record Check
Looking at a used car, check for costly hidden problems before you buy.