Search Consumer Guide Auto and the Web
 

1997-2004 Porsche Boxster Road Test
Date Published: 2/20/08
Our road test for this generation Porsche Boxster includes a full evaluation from the inside out. We've evaluated every aspect of the Porsche Boxster and highlighted the vehicle's performance with pros and cons. Use our comprehensive road test ratings to decide if this generation Porsche Boxster is right for you.
1997-2004 Porsche Boxster Road Test
Pros Cons
Steering/handling Noise
Acceleration Ride
Braking Passenger room
Side airbags (1998-up)
Consumer Guide® Road-Test Evaluation
Looks are just the starting point of the Boxster's appeal. It may be the latest "budget" Porsche, but the Boxster is no less a thoroughbred sports car than its big-brother 911. This roadster entertains most on twisty roads, tracking with grippy sure-footed stability, little body lean, and sure control, aided by rifle-quick steering with ample feedback. Unfortunately, the penalty for this handling prowess is an annoyingly stiff ride, with constant minor pitching on some freeways, and lots of thumpy jiggle over tar strips and patches. Add in marked noise from engine, wind, and tires, and the Boxster would be wearing on a long Interstate trip. Although the engine is strongest at higher rpm, there's enough low-end torque for punchy standing starts and quick passing sprints. Still, our manual-shift test car disappointed slightly in the 0-60 mph test at 7.5 seconds (Porsche claims 6.7). Fuel economy is excellent for the performance, however. We averaged a laudable 21.7 mpg in spirited city/highway driving. "Panic" braking is arresting-cable swift. Mash the pedal and the Boxster just hunkers down and stops. Some drivers feel cramped in a Boxster, even with the top down, while others have no complaints. Audio and climate controls are handy but confusing. Many drivers would prefer a tilt steering wheel instead of the standard telescopic adjustment. As it is, the wheel rim tends to mask part of the tachometer face. Additional gripes: an old-fashioned floor-hinged gas pedal; analog and digital speedometers; no in-dash glovebox; and no top-side engine access other than three "service" ports in the rear trunk. On the plus side, the Boxster's two cargo holds (front and rear) take a fair bit of stuff for a 2-seater, the seats are supportively comfortable, and visibility is okay despite a "bathtub" driving position and the soft top's fairly blind rear quarters. That top works quickly and seals well, but isn't completely covered when folded under its lid. Also, the plastic rear window seems cheap at this price. The optional behind-the-seats wind blocker is effective, but cumbersome to remove or install. Boxster is solid and rattle-free for a modern ragtop. One test car had some body shake over railroad tracks, though paint was gorgeous and panel fits precise--a sharp contrast to the thin, cheap-looking black plastic used on the dashboard and console.
Value for the Money
As a more affordable Porsche, the Boxster is mainly for those who appreciate a Porsche's special virtues. BMW's 6-cylinder Z3 2.8 is a more "traditional" sports car that's close in performance, while some observers favor the Mercedes-Benz as the best all-around machine. All are good in their way, and cost about the same, so take your pick. No, it's not perfect; but Boxster is a genuine sports car, and genuinely entertaining on the road.
Consumer Guide® Road Test Ratings
Porsche Boxster Rating
Performance 7
Fuel Economy 5
Ride Quality 2
Steering/Handling/Braking 8
Quietness 1
Controls/Materials 3
Interior Room 4
Room/Comfort (rear) 0
Cargo Capacity 2
Value within Class 2
Total: 34
Each vehicle report contains one rating chart for representative model. Consumer Guide® rates in ten key areas: Performance, Fuel Economy, Ride Comfort, Steering and Handling, Interior Noise, Controls and Materials, Driver Room, Passenger Room, Cargo Capacity, and Insurance Costs. These ratings compare the particular vehicle rated to ALL other vehicles, not a vehicle's standing in a particular class. In the ratings table, "1" is the lowest rating and "10" is the highest rating.
Car Buying Resources

Trade-In Calculator

Research how much your car is truly worth

Trade-In Calculator



Used Cars

Search online classifieds and find a local dealer
Search Local Listings

Vehicle History Report

Get a CARFAX Vehicle History... the first step to protecting yourself from costly hidden problems.



What's Under the Hood?

Learn about how cars work.

Learn things



Insurance

We're dedicated to making insurance easier.

Get Insurance



Sell Your Car

Reach over 8 million buyers
Sell Your Car
    Find a Used Car
Price Range:
to
 Radius:
    Vehicle History Report

FREE CARFAX Record Check
Looking at a used car, check for costly hidden problems before you buy.